Bipin's Wine Notes, by Bipin Desai.

Fredy Girardet, the culinary giant of our time
--my letter to him upon his retirement. 

It is a rare piece of luck to have lived in the same era as Fredy Girardet, considered by most everyone, particularly the chefs around the world, as one of the greatest chefs of our time; and to have partaken some of his greatest culinary creations.

I have not always been that lucky. In one of my other passionate hobbies, jazz, I never got to see the greatest saxophonist of my time, John Coltrane, play in person. Spellbinding as he was in his records, he was immensely more so in live performances. I've always regretted that I was deprived of that experience.

So when I heard in the fall of 1996 that Girardet was going to retire, I wanted my unforgettable experiences at his restaurant to be somehow memorialized.

Besides the novel dishes, which he created almost spontaneously, it his sauces that were the most memorable. If you can think of the concentration in a Chateau Lafleur from a great vintage combined with the perfume and the complexity of a Romanee Conti-- a combination impossible in the context of wine making--that is how his greatest sauces were--totally out of this world.

Instead of giving him a present, therefore, like a bottle of wine, or sending him a card, I wrote a letter reminiscing about my many visits at his restaurant in Crissier, Switzerland. I hand delivered it to him when I was at Chez Girardet for the last time on September 27,28 1996.

The letter did not take very long for me to write because, as you will notice, the words come right from the heart. 

Dear Fredy,

I was very sad to hear that you will be retiring in just a few months.

Blaire always said that no matter which direction I traveled, I always found a way to stop by Crissier.

Having eaten at Chez Girardet more than 70 times the past 19 years, it is going to be very difficult to bring one of my life's most pleasurable trips to an abrupt halt.

But instead of being sad, I wanted to thank you by reminiscing about some of my visits here.

It all started in the year before the TGV existed, when I took a slow train from Paris to Lausanne just to have lunch here. I left at six in the morning, arrived at Crissier around noon, and after the typically slow meal I take -- made even slower because I could not resist savoring every morsel of the food and every drop of the sauce -- I returned to Paris at midnight.

Most people thought I was crazy to spend 18 hours just to have a meal. But I knew that never in my life, until then, had I found so much innovation and such concentration of flavors as I did in the dishes you served.

So, I kept coming back.

Once I found myself in the middle of the filming of "60 minutes" here. When the program was aired in the U.S., it included a two-second view of my eating. My "secret passion" was out among my friends who recognized me.

A landmark in my life was the fall of 1983 when I was on my second sabbatical at the nuclear Institute, CERN, in Geneva. Blaire and I ate here every Tuesday and Wednesday for three months. Every dish was extraordinary, not a single dish was repeated

My friend Wolfgang Grunewald likes to tell about his first visit to Girardet when he joined me for lunch many years ago. When we arrived we found that there was a mix-up in the reservations. No tables were available. With profuse apologies the waiters installed a table for the two of us, right in the middle of the room! Wolfgang, who is normally extremely sensitive to locations, found the meal so incredible, he was totally oblivious to the surroundings!

He also tells me that whenever he is here with me, he notices that I frequently hum as I savor your dishes.

It is actually singing, I tell him, without words, just pure pleasure.

On behalf of Blaire and myself and scores of my friends who have eaten here, I wanted to say how lucky we are to have had Fredy Girardet as such an important part for lives. A place which is, without a doubt, the greatest restaurant in the world.

It is this feeling of gratitude from us which I hope you will keep with you as you retire.

All the Best Wishes.

Regards,

Bipin

Wine cellar at Chez Girardet

He always had excellent wine selections and very knowledgeable sommeliers. Here I learned about Pierre Morey's Montrachets, Guy Roulot's Meursaults, and had fabulous old vintages of Leroy, Rousseau, and DRC among many others.

He had a superb selection of Italian wines, which as a general rule, never used to appear in the lists of three star restaurants (by sheer coincidence I recently met the person responsible for his Italian selections, Francesco Battuello. He, Wolfgang and I have gotten together several times with Girardet since his retirement)

One wine story at Girardet tops all others, however : Until the mid-' 80s their "house wine" for me was 1961 Hermitage La Chapelle by Jaboulet. This was before it had been proclaimed as the "wine of the century" or a "100-point" wine and so on. It was much, much cheaper then.

There would be a bottle of it waiting for me almost every time I came for a meal . Then one day when I arrived for lunch, the day after I had consumed the 1961 for dinner, the sommelier came over to me.

He was white as a sheet.

He told me he had committed a big faux pas. He had discovered the previous night that no 1961 was left in the restaurant's cellar. Not wanting to disappoint me, he took a bottle from Girardet's small personal collection instead. He told me that when Girardet found out about it that morning, he was "none too happy" (he probably meant "livid" but could only muster the mildest version of it !). Girardet also came over and explained the situation to me.

I laughed and put both of them at ease. As it so happened I had bought a case of it years before, out of which I had 10 bottles left (now it is down to 6). So I brought a bottle back the following trip and peace was restored.

What replaced it? It was another Rhone. Nowhere near the quality of the 1961, but a splendidly drinking 1967 Chateauneuf du Pape Les Cedres also from Jaboulet (1967 is an excellent vintage in Chateauneuf, as it is also in Piedmont). It has that unmistakable Chateuneuf character of an "animal nose", with very opulent flavors, but still balanced.

When the restaurant's cellar was auctioned off by Sotheby's two years ago a great many wines, mostly quite extraordinary, were sold off at high prices.

I formed a group with few of my friends and bought everything they had of that 1967 Chateauneuf --more than 10 cases.

We also got many treasures which you won't find mentioned in any books unless you've had it yourself as, fortunately, I had :Gilette 1953, 1955, Laville Haut Brion 1955, Lynch Bages 1955, Figeac 1961, Pape Clement 1962, many Rayas, de Montille, Leroy and so on.

Top of Page

© 2004-2005 Bipin Desai